America's oldest continuously operating winery, founded in 1839 in Washingtonville. Historic stone-walled underground cellars are open for daily tours that trace the history of American winemaking through the Civil War, Prohibition (when the winery survived by producing sacramental wine), and the modern era. Produces a wide range of wines plus distilled spirits and a small tasting room program. Located on a sprawling 19th-century property with weddings, concerts, and seasonal events including a popular harvest festival.
Verified October 2026
Own or manage Brotherhood — America's Oldest Winery? Claim this listing or send us corrections to your hours, description, phone, or anything else. Updates are usually made within a few days.